US Judge Acquits Brothers in Landmark $25 Million Ethereum Exploit Case
Share
A US federal judge has acquitted two brothers accused of orchestrating a first-of-its-kind automated exploit that siphoned $25 million in cryptocurrency from the Ethereum blockchain in approximately 12 seconds.
Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno, both former students at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), were cleared of wire fraud and money laundering charges on 17 November 2026. US District Judge Jessica Clarke ruled that the prosecution failed to provide evidence that the pair made material misrepresentations, which is a critical requirement for a wire fraud conviction under federal law.
The judge stated that the question before the court was not whether the conduct was right or moral, but whether the evidence could support the specific charges brought by the government. Because the prosecution could not prove that the defendants made false statements or material deceptions during the execution of the scheme, a judgment of acquittal was entered.
The MEV-Boost Relay Exploit
The case involved a highly sophisticated technical operation that targeted the transaction validation process on the Ethereum network. Prosecutors alleged that the brothers exploited a vulnerability in the Maximal Extractable Value (MEV) boost relay code.
By using “bait transactions,” the pair allegedly induced the relay to release the full content of a proposed block prematurely. This allowed them to gain access to pending private transactions, reorder the blocks to their advantage, and seize assets from other traders. The entire process was executed with such speed that the funds were moved before the victims could react.
The government claimed the brothers spent months preparing for the attack, beginning in late 2022. This preparation reportedly included searching for information on how to conceal their identities, setting up shell companies, and using foreign cryptocurrency exchanges with lax verification procedures to launder the proceeds.
Legal Limits in Decentralised Finance
The acquittal highlights the ongoing difficulty of applying traditional fraud and theft laws to decentralised finance (DeFi) exploits. Unlike traditional phishing or business email compromise attacks, which rely on deceiving humans, this scheme targeted the underlying logic and vulnerabilities of blockchain protocols.
The defence argued that the brothers had simply interacted with the blockchain’s code as it was written, effectively outmanoeuvring other participants within the rules of the system. The court’s decision suggests that exploiting a bug or a logic flaw in a protocol may not inherently constitute wire fraud unless the act involves a specific, provable misrepresentation to another party.
The brothers had been facing up to 20 years in prison for each count. This ruling follows a mistrial in 2025, where a jury was unable to agree on whether the pair’s actions met the legal definition of the crimes charged.
The outcome is expected to have significant implications for how regulators and law enforcement agencies approach “code is law” arguments in future cybercrime cases involving automated trading and blockchain vulnerabilities.




Leave a Reply